Little Guy's Valentine is the Darth Vader cookie. We used this chocolate roll-out cookie recipe (review coming soon) and Buddy's Star Wars cookie cutters. I stole the phrase "Come to the dark side, we have cookies" from a vinyl lettered sign a friend of my sister-in-law gave to her. I've been trying to come up with an excuse for my own such sign, but we (kids aside) aren't really that into Star Wars. Then again, neither is my sister-in-law. I forgot to make the kids each write their names (except for Buddy), so I had Little Guy draw on a red light saber.
Buddy loved this Swedish Fish Valentine idea, but since we homeschool, and our Valentine's Day party is with other homeschoolers, the "same school" phrase was a stretch. My Facebook friends came through for me though with a handful of suggestions:
Princess Sparkley's Valentine was supposed to look more like this, but she wanted the phrase "I've got my eye on you!" and our party grew to 40+ kids so she didn't want to write that out 40+ times. We typed it, then we got lazy about gluing the white paper onto nice, colorful cardstock. She fancied them up by drawing monsters or animals on some of the eyeballs and added a lollipop on back.